César

When we first started dating in 2016, one of the fine dining restaurants that wanted to take out my then-girlfriend Jun was Chef’s Table at Brooklyn Fare. At its original location in Brooklyn, it was considered one of the best restaurants in the city with notoriously difficult reservations (back then, you had to make a phone call hoping that someone on the other line would respond). The reservation became much easier to secure after the restaurant moved to Manhattan’s Midtown West and we were able to have a fantastic dinner from chef Cèsar Ramirez, enjoying the seafood-centric tasting menu with Japanese influence. Since then, chef Cèsar was embroiled in a legal dispute with his former partner and departed Brooklyn Fare to eventually open his own namesake restaurant in 2024. On our recent visit to NYC, we met up with another foodie couple who suggested we try Cèsar. Overall, the food was pretty delicious, but I was hoping to see a bit more evolution from what we had experienced at Brooklyn Fare.

Just like Brooklyn Fare, the tasting menu at Cèsar still leans strongly toward seafood and Japanese influence. We both felt the opening bites started strong, from the delicious sawara (Spanish mackerel) “cigar” to hiramasa on nori chip to kisu (Japanese whiting fish) playfully weaved in a potato crisp; I was particularly fond of the monaka with a complex mix of flavors and ingredients led by royal red shrimp balanced against the thin wafers. The bluefin tuna mixed with butternut squash in a parfait form was one of the best dishes of the night that I would love to revisit again at some point, with the wonderful textural combination between tuna and squash. Another dish that I thought really hit the mark was diver scallop that tasted so tender and meaty; it came with squid in green sauce made from sunchoke that complemented the scallop more or less perfectly.

Compared to these high points, however, I also felt other dishes didn’t quite make the statement that I was hoping for. One of the signature dishes from chef Cèsar during his time at Brooklyn Fare was a sea urchin toast; at Cèsar, we got the same sea urchin toast with black truffle again. Perhaps the chef could’ve added some unexpected twists to the toast which has now become a staple in many fine dining restaurants? The lubina (Spanish name for European sea bass) that came with Chardonnay wine sauce was mostly fine but not the most memorable part of our dinner, as was the case for veal from Southern France that came with cipollini onion and potato tuille. The chef himself stopped by to serve the sauce, but then quickly left without time for a small talk that Jun wanted to initiate by showing him our picture from our visit to Brooklyn Fare. One of the best dishes we had had at Brooklyn Fare was the wonderfully delicate frozen almond soufflé; this time we were served one with chocolate flavor instead. It was still super delicious but again I had to wonder if chef Cèsar was running out of new ideas or just wanted to stick to what had been doing all these years in NYC.

Our friend booked the reservation at Cèsar and upon a casual look on the Resy website, the reservation doesn’t seem terribly difficult compared to other popular fine dining restaurants in NYC. The service was mostly fine but the atmosphere of the dining space felt strangely sterile without a ton of energy or dynamism. Instead of a more casual and intimate setting at Brooklyn Fare, I felt like chef Cèsar’s new project has become more “corporatized.” The wine list at Cèsar, not surprisingly was top notch and we enjoyed our meal with a couple of nice Champagne bottles. I think for diners relatively experienced with fine dining, Cèsar may not blow your mind; its focus is on fresh ingredients and solid execution similar to Brooklyn Fare. I guess I wanted to see chef Cèsar push the envelop from his successful formula a little bit more to turn his eponymous place into a truly memorable dining destination.

KenScale: 8.25/10 (Jun’s Score: 8.25/10)

Address: 333 Hudson St, New York, NY 10013

Website: https://www.cesar.restaurant/

Reservation: None

Leave a Reply